Sicily without Mycenae: A Cross-Cultural Consumption Analysis of Connectivity in the Bronze Age Central Mediterranean
Issue: Vol 30 No. 1 (2017)
Journal: Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology
Subject Areas: Ancient History Archaeology
DOI: 10.1558/jmea.32914
Abstract:
During the Middle Bronze Age in Sicily, there is evidence for material contact with several extra-insular societies, not least with the contemporary Mycenaean culture based in the Aegean. This Mycenaean connection typically receives the most attention, and has been used as the basis to posit the broad acculturation of Sicilian society to Aegean norms, despite a rather limited amount of evidence. To complement the empirical data of genuine imports, interpretations of Aegean influence have also been applied to Sicilian material expressions. In this study, I argue that such acculturation frameworks are too limited to analyse properly the material changes that occur in Sicily, as they rely heavily on the uncertain physical presence of ‘Mycenaeans’ on the island, and do not engage with Sicilian agency or motivations. Instead, I propose a framework borrowed from current globalisation studies, whereby what has been accepted, rejected, or heavily adapted from external sources is given equal interpretive weighting. This consumption-focused perspective also considers the likelihood of disparate systems of value and meaning. The result is an interpretive framework in which prehistoric Sicilians do not fade into the background during the Middle Bronze Age and are not overshadowed by the primary place given to Aegean influence and activity.
Author: Anthony Russell
References :
Albanese Procelli, R.M.
2003a Produzione metallugica di età protostorica nella Sicilia centro-occidentale. In A. Corretti (ed.), Quarte giornate internazionale di studi sull’area Elima, 11-28. Pisa: Scuola Normale Superiore di Pisa.
2003b Sicani, Siculi, Elimi: forme di identità, modi di contatto e processi di trasformazione. Milan: Longanesi.
Alberti, G.
2006 Per una ‘gerachia sociale’ a Thapsos: analisi contestuale delle evidenze funerarie e segni di stratificazione. Rivista di Scienze Preistoriche 56: 369-427.
2007 Minima Thapsiana. Riflessioni sulla cronologia dell’abito di Thapsos. Rivista di Scienza Preistoriche 57: 363-76.
2013 A Bayesian 14C chronology of Early and Middle Bronze Age Sicily: towards an independent absolute dating. Journal of Archaeological Science 40: 2502-14. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2012.08.014
Appadurai, A.
1990 Disjuncture and difference in the global economy. Theory, Culture and Society 7: 295-310. https://doi.org/10.1177/026327690007002017
Bernabò Brea, L.
1957 Sicily before the Greeks. London: Thames and Hudson.
Bietti Sestieri, A.M.
1988 The ‘Mycenaean connection’ and its impact on the central Mediterranean societies. Dialoghi di Archeologia 6: 23-51.
Blake, E.
2008 The Mycenaeans in Italy: a minimalist position. Papers of the British School at Rome 76: 1-34. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0068246200000398
Branigan, K.
1970 Wessex and Mycenae: some evidence reviewed. Wiltshire Archaeological Magazine 65: 89-107.
Broodbank, C.
2013 The Making of the Middle Sea: A History of the Mediterranean from the Beginning to the Emergence of the Classical World. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Budd, P., A.M. Pollard, B. Scaife and R.G. Thomas
1995 Oxhide ingots, recycling and the Mediterranean metals trade. Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology 8: 1-32. https://doi.org/10.1558/jmea.v8i1.1
Castellana, G.
2000 La cultura del Medio Bronzo nell’Agrigentino ed i rapporti con il mondo Miceneo. Palermo: Regione Siciliana. Assessorato Regione Beni Culturali Ambientali e della Pubblica Istruzione.
2002 La Sicilia nel II Millennio a.C. Triskeles Collana di Studi Acheologici. Rome: Salvatore Sciascia.
Childe, V.G.
1939 The Orient and Europe. American Journal of Archaeology 43: 10-26. https://doi.org/10.2307/499132
Classen, C.
1996 Sugar cane, Coca-Cola and hypermarkets: consumption and surrealism in the Argentine northwest. In D. Howes (ed.), Cross-cultural Consumption: Global Markets and Local Realities, 39-54. London and New York: Routledge.
Cox, D.R.
1977 Barbie and her playmates. Journal of Popular Culture 11: 303-307. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.0022-3840.1977.00303.x
Cultraro, M.
2005 Le relazioni tra Sicilia e penisola Iberica in età Postmicenea: una nota. In S. Celestino Pérez and J. Jiménez Ávila (eds.), El periodo Orientalizante. Actas del III simposio internacional de arqueología de Mérida: protohistoria del Mediterráneo occidental. Anejos de Archivo español de arqueología 35: 97-106. Mérida: Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas.
Cusick, J.G.
1998 Historiography of acculturation: an evaluation of concepts and their application in archaeology. In J.G. Cusick (ed.), Studies in Culture Contact: Interaction, Culture Change, and Archaeology. Center for Archaeological Investigations, Occasional Paper 25: 126-45. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University.
D’Agata, A.L.
2000 Interactions between Aegean groups and local communities in Sicily in the Bronze Age: the evidence from the pottery. Studi Micenei ed Egeo-Anatolici 42: 61-83.
De Miro, E.
1996 Recenti ritrovamenti micenei nell’Agrigento e il villaggio di Cannatello. In E. De Miro, L. Godart and A. Sacconi (eds.), Atti e memorie del secondo congresso internazionale di Micenologia. Incunabula Graeca 98: 995-1011. Rome: Gruppo Editoriale Internazionale.
1999a Archai della Sicilia Greca. Presenze Egeo-Cipriote sulla costa meridionale dell’isola. L’emporio miceneo di Cannatello. In La colonisation Greque en Méditerranée occidentale. Collection de l’École Française de Rome 251: 71-81. Rome: École Française de Rome.
1999b Un emporio miceneo sulla costa sud della Sicilia. In V. La Rosa, D. Palermo and L. Vagnetti (eds.), Epι pontoν plazomenoι, 439-49. Rome: Scuola Archeologica Italiana di Atene.
Deorsola, D.
1996 Il villaggio del Medio Bronzo di Cannatello presso Agrigento. In E. De Miro, L. Godart and A. Sacconi (eds.), Atti e memorie del secondo congresso internazionale di Micenologia. Incunabula Graeca 98(3): 1029-38. Rome: Gruppo Editoriale Internazionale.
Dietler, M.
1998 Consumption, agency, and cultural entanglement: theoretical implications of a Mediterranean colonial encounter. In J.G. Cusick (ed.), Studies in Culture Contact: Interaction, Culture Change, and Archaeology. Center for Archaeological Investigations, Occasional Paper 25: 126-45. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University.
2005 The archaeology of colonization and the colonization of archaeology. In G.J. Stein (ed.), The Archaeology of Colonial Encounters: Comparative Perspectives, 33-68. Santa Fe, New Mexico: School for Advanced Research Press.
Doonan, O.
2001 Domestic architecture and settlement planning in Early and Middle Bronze Age Sicily: thoughts on innovation and social process. Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology 14: 159-88.
Dunbabin, T.J.
1948 The Western Greeks: The History of Sicily and South Italy from the Foundation of the Greek Colonies to 480 bc. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
Feuer, B.
2011 Being Mycenaean: a view from the periphery. American Journal of Archaeology 115: 507-36. https://doi.org/10.3764/aja.115.4.0507
Friedman, J.
1990 Being in the world: globalization and localization. Theory, Culture and Society 7: 311-28. https://doi.org/10.1177/026327690007002018
Galaty, M.L.
2016 The Mycenaeanisation process. In E. Gorogianni, P. Pavúk and L. Girella (eds.), Beyond Thalassocracies: Understanding Processes of Minoanisation and Mycenaeanisation in the Aegean, 207-18. Oxford: Oxbow Books.
Giannitrapani, E.
2009 Nuove considerazioni sulla diffusione del Bicchiere Campaniforme in Sicilia. Rivista di Scienze Preistoriche 59: 219-42.
Giardino, C.
1995 Il Mediterraneo Occidentale fra XIV ed VII Secolo a.C: Cerchie Minerarie e Metallurgiche. The West Mediterranean between the 14th and 8th Centuries B.C.: Mining and Metallurgical Spheres. British Archaeological Reports, International Series 612. Oxford: Tempus Reparatum.
Gillis, C.
1995 Trade in the Late Bronze Age. In C. Gillis, C. Risberg and B. Sjöberg (eds.), Trade and Production in Premonetary Greece: Aspects of Trade. Studies in Mediterranean Archaeology and Literature, Pocket-book 134: 61-86. Jonsered: P. Åströms Förlag.
Hannerz, U.
1992 Cultural Complexity: Studies in the Social Organization of Meaning. New York: Columbia University Press.
Harding, A.F.
1984 The Mycenaeans and Europe. London: Academic Press.
Harpster, M.
2013 Shipwreck identity, methodology, and nautical archaeology. Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory 20: 588-622. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10816-012-9131-x
Hodos, T.
2010 Globalization and colonization: a view from Iron Age Sicily. Journal of Mediterranean Archaeology 23: 81-106. https://doi.org/10.1558/jmea.v23i1.81
Howes, D.
1996 Introduction: commodities and cultural borders. In D. Howes (ed.), Cross-cultural Consumption: Global Markets and Local Realities, 1-16. London: Routledge. https://doi.org/10.1017/cbo9780511581939.001
Iacono, F.
2015 Feasting at Roca: cross-cultural encounters and society in the southern Adriatic during the Late Bronze Age. European Journal of Archaeology 18: 259-81. https://doi.org/10.1179/1461957114Y.0000000074
Jiménez, A.
2010 Reproducing difference: mimesis and colonialism in Roman Hispania. In P. van Dommelen and A.B. Knapp (eds.), Material Connections in the Ancient Mediterranean: Mobility, Materiality and Identity, 38-63. London and New York: Routledge.
Jones, R.E., and P.M. Day
1987 Late Bronze Age Aegean and Cypriot-type pottery on Sardinia: identification of imports and local imitations by physico-chemical analysis. In M. S. Balmuth (ed.), Nuragic Sardinia and the Mycenaean World. Studies in Sardinian Archaeology 3. British Archaeological Reports, International Series 387: 257-70. Oxford: British Archaeological Reports.
Jones, R.E., S.T. Levi and M. Bettelli
2005 Mycenaean pottery in the central Mediterranean: imports, imitations and derivatives. In R. Laffineur and E. Greco (eds.), Emporia: Aegeans in the Central and Eastern Mediterranean. Aegaeum 25(2): 539-45. Liège, Austin: Université de Liège, University of Texas at Austin.
Jones, R.E., S.T. Levi, M. Bettelli and L. Vagnetti
2014 Italo-Mycenaean Pottery: The Archaeological and Archaeometric Dimensions. Incunabula Graeca 103. Rome: Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche.
Knapp, A.B.
1990 Ethnicity, entrepreneurship, and exchange: Mediterranean inter-island relations in the Late Bronze Age. Annual of the British School at Athens 85: 115-53.
2008 Prehistoric and Protohistoric Cyprus: Identity, Insularity, and Connectivity. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Leighton, R.
1999 Sicily Before History: An Archaeological Survey from the Palaeolithic to the Iron Age. Ithaca, New York: Cornell University Press.
2005 Later prehistoric settlement patterns in Sicily: old paradigms and new surveys. European Journal of Archaeology 8: 261-87. https://doi.org/10.1177/1461957105076066
Levi, S.T.
2004 Produzioni artigianali: la ceramica. Circolazione dei produtti e organizzazione della manufattura. In D. Cocchi Genick (ed.), L’ Età del Bronzo Recente in Italia, 233-42. Viareggio: Mauro Baroni.
Lo Schiavo, F.
2003 Sardinia between east and west: interconnections in the Mediterranean. In N. C. Stampolidis and V. Karageorghis (eds.), ΠΛΟΕΣ…Sea Routes…Interconnections in the Mediterranean 16th-6th c. bc, 15-33. Athens: A.G. Leventis Foundation.
2008 Oxhide ingots in the central Mediterranean: recent perspectives. In I. Tzachili (ed.), Aegean Metallurgy in the Bronze Age, 227-45. Athens: Ta Pragmata.
Macdougall, J.P.
2003 Traditional commodities as local cultural icons: Barbie dolls in Mexico. Journal of Popular Culture 37: 257-75. https://doi.org/10.1111/1540-5931.00067
Maniscalco McConnell, L.
1996 Early Bronze Age funerary ritual and architecture: monumental tombs at Santa Febronia. In R. Leighton (ed.), Early Societies in Sicily: New Developments in Archaeological Research. Accordia Specialist Studies on Italy 5: 81-87. London: Accordia Research Centre.
McConnell, B.E.
1992 The Early Bronze Age village of La Muculufa and prehistoric hut architecture in Sicily. American Journal of Archaeology 96: 23-44. https://doi.org/10.2307/505756
Mederos Martin, A.
1999 Ex occidente lux. El commercio micénico en el Mediterráneo central y occidental (1625-1100 AC). Complutum 10: 229-66.
Militello, P.
2004a Commercianti, architetti ed artigiani: riflessioni sulla presenza micenea nell’area Iblea. In V. La Rosa (ed.), Le presenze Micenee nel territorio Siricusano. I simposio Siricusano di preistoria Sciliana in Memoria di Paolo Orsi, 295-336. Padova: Bottega d’Erasmo.
2004b Due nuove tholoi dal Medio Irminio. In V. La Rosa (ed.), Le presenze Micenee nel territorio Siricusano. I simposio Siricusano di preistoria Sciliana in Memoria di Paolo Orsi, 269-94. Padova: Bottega d’Erasmo.
Miller, D.
2006 Consumption. In C. Tilley, W. Keane, S. Kuechler, M. Rowlands and P. Spyer (eds.), Handbook of Material Culture, 341-54. London: Sage. https://doi.org/10.4135/9781848607972.n23
Nederveen Pieterse, J.
2015 Globalization and Culture: Global Mélange. 3rd edn. Lanham, Maryland: Rowman and Littlefield.
Orsi, P.
1895 Thapsos. Monumenti Antichi dei Lincei 6: 89-150.
Renfrew, A.C.
1968 Wessex without Mycenae. Annual of the British School at Athens 63: 277-85. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0068245400014416
1977 Alternative models for exchange and spatial distribution. In T.K. Earle and J.E. Ericson (eds.), Exchange Systems in Prehistory, 71-90. New York: Academic Press. https://doi.org/10.1016/b978-0-12-227650-7.50010-9
Rizzone, V.G., A.M. Sammito and G. Terranova
2004 Per un corpus delle tholoi dell’area Iblea. In V. La Rosa (ed.), Le presenze Micenee nel territorio Siricusano. I simposio Siricusano di preistoria Sciliana in Memoria di Paolo Orsi, 217-63. Padova: Bottega d’Erasmo.
Russell, A.
2011 In the Middle of the Corrupting Sea: Cultural Encounters in Sicily and Sardinia between 1450 – 900 bc. Unpublished PhD dissertation, Department of Archaeology, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, UK.
2016 We are not you: being different in Bronze Age Sicily. In E. Pierce, A. Russell, A. Maldonado and L. Campbell (eds.), Creating Material Worlds: The Uses of Identity in Archaeology. Oxford: Oxbow Books.
Smith, T.R.
1987 Mycenaean Trade and Interaction in the West Central Mediterranean 1600-1000 bc. British Archaeological Reports, International Series 371. Oxford: British Archaeological Reports.
Stein, G.
2002 From passive periphery to active agents: emerging perspectives in the archaeology of interregional interaction. American Anthropologist 104: 903-16. https://doi.org/10.1525/aa.2002.104.3.903
Tanasi, D.
2004 Per un riesame degli elementi di tipo miceneo nella cultura di Pantalica Nord. In V. La Rosa (ed.), Le presenze Micenee nel territorio Siricusano. I simposio Siricusano di preistoria Sciliana in Memoria di Paolo Orsi, 337-83. Padova: Bottega d’Erasmo.
2005 Mycenaean pottery imports and local imatations: Sicily vs southern Italy. In R. Laffineur and E. Greco (eds.), Emporia: Aegeans in the Central and Eastern Mediterranean. Aegeaum 25: 561-69. Liège, Austin: Université de Liège, University of Texas at Austin.
2008 La Sicilia e l’arcipelago Maltese nell’età del Bronzo Medio. Koinè Archeologica Sapiente Antichità 3. Palermo: Officina di Studi Medievali.
2009 Sicily at the end of the Bronze Age: ‘catching the echo’. In C. Bachhuber and R.G. Roberts (eds.), Forces of Transformation: The End of the Bronze Age in the Mediterranean. Themes from the Ancient Near East, BANEA Publication Series 1: 51-58. Oxford: Oxbow Books.
Tanasi, D., and N.C. Vella
2014 Islands and mobility: exploring Bronze Age connectivity in the south-central Mediterranean. In A.B. Knapp and P. van Dommelen (eds.), The Cambridge Prehistory of the Bronze and Iron Age Mediterranean, 57-73. New York: Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/cho9781139028387.007
Taylour, W.
1958 Mycenaean Pottery in Italy and Adjacent Areas. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Tomasello, F.
1995–96 Le tombe a tholos della Sicilia centro meridionale. Cronache di Archeologia e di Storia dell’Arte 34-35. Catania: Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche Centro di Studio sulla Archeologia Greca.
2001 Nuove tombe tholoidi dell’età del Bronzo a Mustanzello di Milena. In M.C. Martinelli and U. Spigo (eds.), Studi di preistoria e protostoria in onore di Luigi Bernabò Brea. Quaderni del Museo Archeologico Regionale Eoliano “Luigi Bernabò Brea” Supplemento 1: 317-30. Palermo: Assessorato Regionale dei Beni Culturali e Ambientali e della Pubblica Istruzione.
2004 L’architettura ‘micenea’ nel Siracusano. To-ko-do-mo a-pe-o o de-me-o-te? In V. La Rosa (ed.), Le presenze Micenee nel territorio Siricusano. I simposio Siricusano di preistoria Sciliana in Memoria di Paolo Orsi, 187-215. Padova: Bottega d’Erasmo.
Tusa, S.
1999a La Sicilia nella preistoria. Nuovo Prisma Collana Diretta da Antonino Buttitta 13. Palermo: Sellerio Editore.
1999b Short-term cultural dynamics within the Mediterranean cultural landscape. In R.H. Tykot, J. Morter and J. Robb (eds.), Social Dynamics of the Prehistoric Central Mediterranean. Accordia Specialist Studies on the Mediterranean 3: 149-83. London: Accordia Research Centre.
2000 La società siciliana e il ‘contatto’ con il Mediterraneo centro-orientale dal II millennio a.C. agli inizi del primo millennio a.C. Sicilia Archeologica 98: 9-39.
2009 Da Mokarta a Monte Polizzo: la transizione dall’età del Bronzo Finale all’età del Fero. In M. Congiu, C. Miccichè and S. Modeo (eds.), ΕIΣ ΑKΡΑ. Insediamenti d’altura in Sicilia dalla preistoria al III sec. a.C., 27-52. Caltanissetta: Salvatore Sciascia Editore.
van Dommelen, P., and M. Rowlands
2012 Material concerns and colonial encounters. In J. Moran and P.W. Stockhammer (eds.), Materiality and Social Practice. Transformative Capacities of Intercultural Encounters, 20-31. Oxford: Oxbow Books.
van Wijngaarden, G.J.
2002 Use and Appreciation of Mycenaean Pottery in the Levant, Cyprus and Italy (1600-1200 bc). Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press. https://doi.
org/10.5117/9789053564820
Versluys, M.J.
2014 Understanding objects in motion: an archaeological dialogue on Romanization. Archaeological Dialogues 21: 1-20. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1380203814000038
Vianello, A.
2005 Late Bronze Age Mycenaean and Italic Products in the West Mediterranean: A Social and Economic Analysis. British Archaeological Reports, International Series 1439. Oxford: Archaeopress.
Voza, G.
1973a Thapsos. Resoconto sulle campagne di scavo del 1970-71. Atti della XV Riunione Scientifica, 133-57. Firenze: Istituto Italiano di Preistoria e Protostoria.
1973b Thapsos. In P. Pelagatti (ed.), Archeologia nella Sicilia Sud-Orientale, 30-52. Napoli: Centre Jean Bérard.
Whitehouse, R.
1972 The rock-cut tombs of the central Mediterranean. Antiquity 46: 275-81. https://doi.org/
10.1017/S0003598X00053874
Wilk, R.
1995 Learning to be local in Belize: global systems of common difference. In D. Miller (ed.) Worlds Apart. Modernity through the Prism of the Local, 110-33. London and New York: Routledge.